Why kids may rate one parent higher after a divorce
Why kids often prefer one parent after a divorce, when it signals something more serious, and how to keep your child out of the middle.

When one parent has traits of sociopathy or narcissism, traditional co-parenting is often impossible. The other parent is left managing constant manipulation,
Best for the Children Editorial·6 min read·September 19, 2026
When one parent has traits of sociopathy or narcissism, traditional co-parenting is often impossible. The other parent is left managing constant manipulation, boundary violations, and attempts to control the narrative — all while trying to protect the children from the emotional fallout.
The goal is not to “win” against the difficult parent. The goal is to create as much stability and emotional safety for the children as possible, while protecting your own ability to parent effectively.
People with strong narcissistic or sociopathic traits rarely change their behavior in response to reasonable requests or explanations.
They often view the children as extensions of themselves or as tools in the ongoing battle. Empathy is limited or absent, and the other parent is seen as an enemy to be defeated rather than a co-parent to work with. This makes standard communication and compromise strategies not only ineffective but sometimes dangerous for the children’s emotional health.
Parallel parenting — where each parent runs their household independently with minimal direct interaction — becomes the more realistic and protective model in these situations. The focus shifts from “co-parenting” to “disengaging while still parenting.”
JADE (Justify, Argue, Defend, Explain) is a trap. When the high-conflict parent accuses or provokes, the natural instinct is to explain yourself, argue your side, defend your choices, or justify your actions. This is exactly what they want — emotional engagement and a chance to keep the fight going. Every time you JADE, you hand them power and prolong the conflict. Instead, use short, neutral responses that do not invite further discussion.
High-conflict parents often use predictable tactics to pull you back into chaos. Here are common scenarios and Gray Rock / boundary responses that starve the drama:
Baiting via text (trying to get an emotional rise):“You’re such a terrible parent. The kids hate being with you and they told me so.”
Effective response: “I will only communicate about the children’s schedule and needs through the app. All other topics will not receive a reply.” Accusation about you (public or in front of others):“You never cared about the kids. You only care about yourself and your new life.”
Effective response: “I won’t discuss this. If you have a specific concern about the children’s schedule, please send it through the app.” Drama / manufactured crisis:“The kids are sick and I can’t handle it. You need to come get them right now or I’m calling the police.”
Effective response: “If the children need medical attention, please take them to the doctor and send me the details through the app. I am available for my scheduled time.” Guilt-tripping about the children:“The kids are crying because they miss me. You’re keeping them from their real parent.”
Effective response: “I will not discuss adult feelings or past issues. The children are fine during my time. Please send any schedule questions through the app.”Notice the pattern in effective responses: short, factual, focused only on the children or logistics, and they close the door to further engagement. No explanations, no defense, no JADE.
The children are not messengers, spies, or confidants.
A parent with narcissistic or sociopathic traits will often try to use the children to gather information, deliver messages, or triangulate against the other parent. This puts the children in an impossible emotional position and can lead to long-term anxiety, loyalty conflicts, and trust issues.
Never use the child as a messenger. All communication about the children must go directly between the adults or through the app. Asking a child to “tell your mom…” or “ask your dad…” damages the child’s sense of safety and loyalty. Do not speak negatively about the other parent in front of the children. Even when the other parent’s behavior is harmful, the children still need permission to love both parents without guilt. Badmouthing often backfires and makes the child feel they must defend the other parent. Help the children develop their own voice. Teach them they are allowed to have their own feelings about each parent without being pressured to take sides. Phrases like “It’s okay to love both of us” can be powerful. Watch for signs of emotional manipulation in the children. Sudden anxiety before visits, repeating the other parent’s accusations word-for-word, or feeling responsible for a parent’s happiness are red flags.Related reading: Divorcing a Narcissist: Key Considerations and Practical Tips · Co-Parenting When the Other Parent Is a Narcissist