Thanksgiving in Two Homes: Plan It in October
Thanksgiving is on November 26 this year. The families who have a good day usually settled it in October. How to plan one holiday across two homes, and what to do if…

Learn how to get more parenting time by agreeing on a new schedule or asking a court to modify the order, and how state law affects your case.
Best for the Children Editorial·8 min read·July 8, 2025·Updated October 16, 2026
It's Sunday evening, the bags are packed, and you're handing your kids back for another long stretch until your next weekend. If you want more time than that, you have two routes. You can work out a new schedule with the other parent and have it made official. Or you can ask a court to modify the order, which usually means showing that circumstances have changed and that more time with you serves your child. How hard either route is depends heavily on which state you live in.
You'll often see the claim that fathers "win" custody only about 18% of the time. That figure doesn't trace back to any solid source. The closest real data comes from the Census Bureau's surveys of custodial parents. Fathers were about 15% of custodial parents in 2000 and about 17% in 2013. Mothers made up nearly all the rest.
Those numbers describe who ended up as the custodial parent. They don't describe who won in court. Many custody arrangements are worked out between the parents, so the figures say little about how judges treat fathers who ask for time.
The same 2013 data shows a related gap. Only 31.4% of custodial fathers had a child support agreement, compared with 52.3% of custodial mothers.
The more useful point is this: custody statutes are written in gender-neutral terms. Arizona's law, for example, bars a court from preferring a parent's plan because of the parent's gender or the child's. Your case turns on the rules your state applies to any parent, so that is where to start.
States fall roughly into a few groups. Lists of "best" and "worst" states for fathers go out of date quickly as legislatures change the rules, so check the current statute rather than a ranking.
States that presume equal time.
States that push for maximum time without promising 50/50.
States with no presumption at all.
States with a special rule before any order exists.
States where child support uses its own definition of "shared."
Your state's group tells you what you're up against. In Florida or Kentucky, the law starts from equal time. In Georgia or Washington, you have to build the case for more time from the evidence.
If you and the other parent can talk, this is usually the faster and cheaper path. Propose a specific schedule rather than asking for "more time" in general. For example: every Wednesday overnight, or alternating weeks in summer. A mediator can help if conversations tend to stall.
The step that people skip is getting the agreement approved by the court. A handshake deal can fall apart, and the existing court order is what a judge will enforce if it does.
Some states also allow smaller changes without a full legal fight. In Washington, a parent can seek a "minor" adjustment to the residential schedule without meeting the full modification test. To qualify, the change must meet one of three limits:
The change must also be in the child's best interest.
If the other parent says no, you can ask the court to change the parenting plan. Most states require two things:
Florida made this easier in 2023. Parents no longer have to show that the change in circumstances was "unanticipated." Judges must now put their reasons in written findings of fact. Florida law also says that a parent moving to within 50 miles of the child's primary home may count as a substantial and material change.
So if you've moved closer, your work schedule now fits school hours, or your child's needs have shifted, that may be the change your case rests on.
A common piece of advice is to prove the other parent isn't caring enough. That isn't what the statutes ask for. The legal questions are what has changed and what is best for your child. Criticizing the other parent rarely answers either one.
Washington's factor list is a good guide to what courts weigh, even in other states. Judges look at:
The following steps are practical advice rather than legal requirements, but each one creates evidence on those factors:
Parenting time and child support are separate legal issues. Getting more time doesn't automatically change what you pay. Washington's statute says outright that a schedule change alone is not a basis for changing support.
Child support is also a court-ordered obligation, not part of a co-parenting deal you negotiate. Keep paying what is ordered while you seek more time, and raise support as its own issue if your circumstances justify it.
The same request can be routine in Florida and an uphill climb in Georgia. Local procedures also vary by county. A family-law attorney, or your court's self-help center, can tell you which standard applies and which forms to file.
With that information, you can choose between proposing a new schedule to the other parent and filing to modify the order.